I used to think PBL was just about the culminating products. Now I
Know that PBL is about the sustained inquiry at the beginning, during and at
the end of the PBL itself. I learned that it is not about a stellar beginning
and a few stellar moments along the way, but it is the authentic inquiry that
drives the learning. Students are
engaged throughout the entire process. For example, for my “Magnet Mania” PBL,
I wanted to begin with an amateur magician because I thought that was the only
way to get my students engaged in the learning. When all I really needed to do
was let them loose with the magnets so they could explore what attracts or
repels. The looks on their faces told the story. They loved pulling things
toward them using the more powerful magnets. It didn’t take a “Magic Show” to
get them interested. Now, I do believe that Mrs. Magnet was effective and got
them excited about what was coming next.
In the “Puttering Around the Pond” unit I felt I was much more
effective throughout the whole unit. I found 25 short animal videos that
allowed students to see the animals in their natural habitat with an element of
the food chain/life cycle included. Using the mini-videos for research purposes
each day really got them engaged and kept them engaged. After the first week of
consistent research practice, students came in every day after asking which
animal we were learning about today. I also used a drawing website called
art-hub for kids to help students draw the animal in a simple, relaxed format.
The man works with his kids to draw in an easy, step by step manner. When students
need me to, I just paused the video until they caught up with the class. There
were drawings for almost every animal I tried to find at the pond. This made it
where students felt comfortable drawing because he made it so simple. Between
the research videos and the drawings, I am not sure which one made the
difference. But, the student’s books came to life.
I Used To Think That only upper grade students could really implement
all aspects of the PBL Now I Know That, students of all ages can learn using
the PBL model. My students were more engaged than I have ever seen them before.
It is all due to the way I approached PBL. Yes, it is great when your entire
school has buy in. But, in the age of standardized testing, student
“unaccountability” and pressures on the classroom teachers to do-it-all, that
is a pipe dream I am afraid. Everyone has their own idea of the perfect way to
teach. None of that matters as long as authentic learning is taking place. In
my opinion, the perfect way to facilitate that learning is PBL. I am excited to
see where this journey takes me next year. Thank you Dawn for making this
journey possible for me.
Hi Tina,
ReplyDeleteI really appreciate the time and thought you put into reflecting o your pbl experiences this year. I enjoyed reading how you've seen growth not only in your students through both the magnet and the pond pbl but also in your own practices and in your understanding and ability to implement pbl through effective practices. I like how you utilized short video clips to help your kindergarten students learn necessary and compelling facts about the plants and animals in the pond ecosystem and worked to find resources that would meet them where they are (like the art hub drawing videos) and help them show what they know at their level. I agree wholeheartedly with you that you have learned that upper grades are not the only grades that can fully implement pbl. I agree with you that while whole school buy in is wonderful, what is most important is what goes on in each teacher's classroom and we've learned this year that there are multiple possibilities for effective pbl to take place. Thank you! Dawn