Thursday, December 14, 2017

Kim Trott Blog Post 5

Kimberly Trott Blog Post 5 What I Used to Think/But Now I Know
                When I first heard about Project Based Learning, it was through a meeting at our school in which other teachers were explaining Project Based Learning to fellow teachers through departmental meetings.  It seemed very abstract and more of like, “I do that in my class now.”  At that time, I did many projects in my class but in actuality, they are nothing like what I have found out that PBL projects entail.  Normally in my honors class, I assign the topic, or give them the option to pick between a couple of topics, and then the students go home and make sure their rubric requirements were met.  I did the same for my CP courses but we did the project in class.

                What I know now is that I still have a long way to go.  I have learned that student choice and voice is critical at all stages of the project implementation.  I am working on trying to turn over what I deliver as instruction to the students.  Meaning that I do not have to tell them every single thing they need to know in class.  That through the investigation and project development they should walk away with a sense that they have done their part and are able to take a test without me having to give them everything needed to receive a high grade; that a lot of the burden is on them now to actually read and develop quality work that helps them understand the material.  I also have learned that having a real world project, which is authentic, and has a real audience, is important in order for the project to be relevant in the real world.  Finally, I still need to work on real world soft skills with my students.  I hope to create a one-page chart over the holidays for my desk that reminds me of key features of PBL that I need to work on with my student just as part of the normal routine day.  That from day one of class we need to be working on the skills that makes PBL successful.  

Savannah Griffith Blog Post 5



What I use to think about PBL..

When I first was told I would be taking the class I was nervous. I really had no idea what Problem Based Learning was or how I could use this in my art room. I also knew I would be going through ADEPT, taking the gifted and talented course, read to succeed and coaching cheerleading for the first time. That was and still is a lot on my plate but I am so thankful I chose to still take the class. I thought that it would be too hard and challenging. I also thought that art could not possibly get any better! Boy was I wrong!


What I now know!

I have learned so much this semester in PBL its hard to put into words. I really enjoyed implementing my lesson and seeing the excitement in my students. I now understand that PBL is much more than just a lesson plan like I thought it was this summer. I was able to create a problem scenario and my students were able to create a solution. I absolutely love how different each final product was. I also now know that art is full of problem based learning everyday. I now understand what protocols are and how effect that can be for all lessons. I was basically doing that anyways and did not even know it. I also LOVED genius hour! My students took such care and time on their projects. They also were so creative! I cannot wait to implement a new unit and genius hour next semester!

Wednesday, December 13, 2017

Sarah Kate Chatel - Blog Post 3

I love my job! Being a special education teacher has made me shift my approach with every student, not only the ones who struggle. As a special education teacher I must constantly evaluate student’s present levels, analyze where they are currently, formulate personalized goals and continuously progress monitor their understanding. Through this process, I make goal setting and overall awareness a priority with my students. As teachers, we are every student’s s and it is my top priority to empower students to become their own advocates and develop them into having a growth mindset. A huge part of teaching students who have a disability is to be self-aware and how to pursue the developments of their weaknesses. I strive to conference with my students every Friday, in order to identify weaknesses and develop a game plan for improvement. Working with students that come from poverty, I see the need to develop a growth mindset within students. They must be driven to learn more, become better and go further than they ever thought possible. I believe that every student possesses strengths and weaknesses and is capable of being successful. I aim to meet student’s individual needs and develop a growth mindset amongst all students in order for them to overcome their difficulties in learning and life. 

Sarah Kate Chatel/ Higgins Blog 5

What I thought of PBL
I'm not going to lie, when I initially thought of Project Based Learning, I envisioned an interactive way of teaching that is successful with gifted students. I thought it would be difficult to implement PBL with my students, because they already struggle so much with learning. I questioned if it would actually work with my kids and I worried about giving them more responsibility within their learning, because they are not making appropriate gains with direct instruction. Then I thought, if the traditional approach to teaching is not making connections for them, then what is the harm in trying something new? I entered the course hoping that maybe this would inform me in a different approach to teaching that would benefit even those that struggle.

What I Know Now
I have earned so much throughout this process to becoming PBL certified! I have failed at some things and seen success and growth at many. I loved learning about and implementing a variety of consensus protocols throughout my unit. The silent debate as well as the student lead rubric making stood out to me throughout my experience. I saw students invest into their learning and become passionate about their project because it was all about them and their future career goals. My students developed an understanding for the importance of acting, speaking and presenting themselves professionally in order to be considered as a quality candidate for a job. One area I would like to focus on is having community and stakeholder involvement. Many of my plans fell through and I was not able to get the community involved within my project. I also wish that I had more opportunity for presentation of materials beyond a whiteboard. Students are so used to a Promethean board or projector that I had to step through many things individually on student computers, rather than with the class on the board. It would have created alot more ease throughout the project to have Promethean board technology within the classroom. All in all I enjoyed my first experience with PBL and I look forward to continuing to attempt implementation of another unit and get feedback to improve within my teaching.

Emily Waddill Course 2 Blog 5

As a result of my first every PBL unit of study myself and my students have learned a great deal. I have learned that sometimes technology isn’t always your friend, but you make the best out of what you have. We had a lot of issues with saving our files, so we had to spend a lot of time on redoing something that wasn’t saved properly the first time. The students were more engaged in this project because it had meaning and relevancy to them. So, in the future I want to teach lessons that connect in some way to their lives.


Once students got the hang of using the excel program, they enjoyed typing in the equations to solve their math problems. Of course they needed to know how to do the problems themselves, but the program really helped a lot. Their group budgets were not as in depth as I had originally planned for and we didn’t have time to format the spreadsheet but they had a chance to view each other’s projects and rate each other. They are very honest with each other on how the projects went, so having a talk about constructive criticism would be good for next time. I also found that things I had planned on only taking one day in my unit plan ended up taking longer. So, in the future more working time will be provided to students. I am looking forward to my next PBL unit in the spring and am excited to see what students create.

Robert Smith's Blog Post 5

What I Used to Think About PBL and What I Know Now
PBL is an exciting curricular distribution method that is effective when well planned. While I do not feel it is applicable in every classroom all of the time, I learned that it can be applicable to most classrooms part of the time. Below I listed a few of the anecdotes I discovered about my thinking throughout this process.
I used to think…
Now I think / know…
PBL was difficult to begin.
I can do it confidently, with a little Googling.
PBL was time consuming.
PBL is time consuming.
PBL was a major undertaking.
PBL is a major undertaking, but it is doable.
Students should try to work at the same pace.
Students learn at their own rate and need to be able to do so.
Projects should have similar looking results.
Projects should be much more than that.
PBL was a little overwhelming.
PBL is very overwhelming.
PBL was only about doing projects.
PBL can be made into the complete curriculum.
PBL was students working independently researching a project.
PBL needs to be collaborative.
I wanted to teach through projects all of the time.
Middle school mathematics is extremely difficult to be project-based all of the time.


Tuesday, December 12, 2017

Taylor Thomas - Course 2: Blog Post 5

What have students learned as evidence by data analysis? Through our PBL learning experience this semester, students learned what Colony Collapse Disorder is, possible theories for CCD, how CCD effects the economy and our food source, stated a claim for the most likely cause of CCD and how they can help with the issue. Based on the analysis of student work, their level of mastery was 93%.

What have you learned? I learned that my CP students needed more guidance than anticipated. I learned that students are proficient in researching and creating products of their findings. I also learned that some students were aware of CCD, but most had never heard of it. Most importantly, I learned more about my students as learners, their work ethic and how they interact in a group setting.  
What worked? The timeframe and timeline for this investigation yielded positive outcomes. The way I organized activities and learning experiences worked well. For the most part, students worked efficiently in their groups. Providing choice in various aspects of this investigation also worked nicely for my students.

What didn’t work? Staking a claim and supporting with evidence did not go so great at first with one of my classes. When I realized students were not successful in supporting a claim with evidence, I gave them examples of how to begin their claim and make it their own. After some guidance, students were successful.


How will this new learning be evident in your next PBL unit? I plan to incorporate a more organized Project Agenda Board in my next PBL unit to provide students with guidelines, checkpoints and expectations. I will thoughtfully pre-assess students and conduct a class discussion on need to knows to hopefully avoid minor setbacks such writing an effective claim and supporting it with evidence. J

Monday, December 11, 2017

Clark H. Maxwell Blog Post #5

What I used to think:

    Prior to this class, I'd heard about PBL before from teachers and my wife, who is also a teacher.  I never really took the time to look and see if this would be a good fit for PE.  I've become so accustomed to setting up games, station work, and fitness testing to think about it.  Initially, I was extremely stressed in the first class.  I had absolutely no idea about anything that was being talked about, still don't at times.  I just tried to figure it out.  But, I can say now that I know how to design and implement one.  My kids were tasked with coming up with a workout that could be done on an extremely tight budget.  They had some good ideas as far a body weight exercises, and using book bags for added weight.  In the beginning, I thought we would work a little bit everyday until we completed it.  That did not work out as planned, too much PE time lost.  Anyway we were able to try-out the works outs a little.  I plan on making them the first workouts I do with my new students next semester.  So my students could actually be with the other PE classes, we all did the workouts in stations and during relays.  We did these for about a week, but did not get to try all of them.  Several students could tell that we were doing an exercise that they had in their workout, and they made sure to let me know.  Right now we are in our last round of fitness testing, so below is a table of how their curl-up/sit-up scores have improved.  There were 85% of my 3rd period who improved.  Some went up big, some small, but Rome wasn't built in a day.  The rest, except for those in red, were within just a few of their previous score.  The two in red thought it would be funny to give up.  I think and hope the main things they got out of the PBL is that a major investment in equipment is not necessary to become fit.  I know I could tell from their technique in the test below that they have gotten in condition.  That is something I harp on them about, technique.  I believe it is a direct result of them being better conditioned

Student
Sit-ups 1
Sit-ups 2
1
20
22
2
7
 21
3
41
 50
4
13
37 
5
30
 46
6
30
 61
7
13
 25
8
24
 42
9
30
 50
10
6
 25
11
30
 50
12
4
 12
13
30
 50
14
16
 17
15
30
 38
16
30
 4
17
30
 25
18
30
 26
19
5
 10
20
30
 50
21
10
 14
22
30
 50
23
30
 50
24
2
 10
25
30
 15
26
13
 22
But Now I know:
    Since taking this class I have been taught ways to do a PBL and have it be more precise.  Now I know not to try and do a little each day.  I'm shooting for once a week, no more no less.  The number one thing I will take from this second class is Genius Hour.  I thought that was the best thing I learned from this class.  It fits very well with PE.  It's quick, simple, I can guide it, and the kids do not dread having to work on PBL stuff everyday.  My plan for next semester is to do Genius Hour once a week until the PBL is finished.  I honestly think this is the best way to do this in PE.

Blog Post #4- Genius Hour Sarah Kate Chatel/ Higgins

I enjoyed implementing the Genius Hour Project within my resource classroom. I allowed my students to have complete choice in the area that they research. I noticed that complete choice sparked the interest of many students, but some students struggled with the lack of structure and had a difficult time picking a specific area. I did provide students with an outlined book that lead them through the process of a genius hour by having them think of a topic of interest, develop three guiding questions and  research those specific areas. I loved watching students learn more about something that interests them. I look forward to incorporating their areas of interest and research into my resource math classroom.
 I loved having the book as a support for my students in order to document what they learned and where they found the information. The next time I plan on implementing a genius hour I would like to have my students use the book as a guide and have more choice within the format for presentation. I can see students enjoying creating a power point, poster, or prezi in order to present their genius hour instead of just straight from the book. I believe that by giving the students choice, it would allow for more creativity and enthusiasm among my students. I would also plan on narrowing the area of research and would love to have students research a college of interest that would provide them a degree or pathway into the career of interest that they did a mock interview for. I look forward to continuing to provide genius hour opportunities within my classroom in the future

Blog #5 Christi Coomes

Christi Coomes Blog #5: What I used to think and now I know

In reflecting on my work this semester, I have revised  and affirmed several theoretical practices. First, the pedagological theory taught in my Master's of Education program was put into practice through the teaching method of compacting in my academically gifted class. Students were given the choice to compact the curriculum in chapter 5 or remain with traditional instruction.  The students were elated to be given to teach themselves through compacting or to have small group instruction (those who remained with traditional teaching).  The compacting motived the students to excel and complete the chapter early so they could work on a Genius Hour Project. The students who participated in the compacting maintained their A average.  The students who participated in the traditional instruction so improvement from chapter 4 to chapter 5 test grades.  For example, one student went from a 74% on chapter 4 to 86% on chapter 5.  The Genius Hour project produced very interesting and well thought out projects ranging from linear regressions to the affects of a, h, and k on quadratic functions.  I will use compacting in the future with my AG classes.

Sometimes theory and practice result in very differing outcomes.  Implementing a PBL has changed my pedagological views on PBL in practice. First, my original plans did not include enough scaffolding for the math concepts.  I will have mini lessons in future PBL projects with students in college preparatory classes which reinforce skills needed in the PBL.  Also, these students needed more accountability assignments than an AG class of students.  I did the PBL with one CP class and traditional teaching with the other CP class.  The PBL class did better on the proportion word problems than the other class.  Therefore, there is affirmation that PBL is a better teaching method for CP students.

Overall, I have learned much through this process which will help me prepare a PBL for next semester which will address some of the successes and failures in my first attempt at PBL.  After F.A.I.L means "first attempt in learning". 

Blog Post #5 What I Used to Think/But Now I Know- Mandy Irick

Blog Post #5
What I Used To Think/But Now I Know

What I used to think about Project Based Learning:
To be honest, one of the major reasons behind me taking this course was to develop my very limited understanding of PBL. The cursory knowledge that I possessed was that it was a paradigm shift composed heavily of the gradual release model of responsibility where students were present in the learning. It was a staunch departure from the more traditional classroom setting where the teacher had primary control of the learning environment and instruction delivery. I had an understanding of the big picture but was at a loss when it came to the different components that made PBL what it is. The other area that I was severally lacking was the implementation aspect. In my mind, PBL would allow students to branch off a skill, standard or concept taught, researching it due to their desire to learn more about it.  This lead to a concern because although exploring interests is very invalid and a proven success, where would the standards connect. The stress of students exploring and researching something that was unrelated from the standards would not allow for mastery nor application. Even though we hate to admit it, testing is important along with staying with the standards. These standards are our road map to how to narrow down the most important information that our students need to know in order to be successful. The other part that I made a wrong assumption on was that it needed to be freer flowing without as many guidelines to not inhibit students’ exploration and growth. This false knowledge made me worried as to how students would stay on track and be successful with their learning and discovery. The biggest part of my learning curve was really the lack of experience I had with construction of a PBL project to the implementation stage. Without having gone through this process, it gave me limited knowledge where I made assumptions to connect the lack of information.

But Now I Know:

After going through course one and two, I feel like I have such a better grasp on the fundamentals. A critical piece in this whole process was being able to have an instructor talk through each section of a functioning PBL unit. This helped to eradicate some previous knowledge that was causing me concern. The other part to this was building my unit from the ground up. I found having to complete every part of the process helped me to gain better insight into what the students would be engaging in. The first misconception to be shattered was that the students could just pick the topic, which could veer radically from the standard or indicator; you are trying to teach them. The teacher needs to make sure that whatever the PBL project is that you can always tie it back into a standard or indicator.  In many of the PBL implemented or I have constructed, the standards are broken down into mini-lessons or activities. The PBL project takes those standards and allow the students to apply them in different and creative ways. I also learned that providing checkpoints along the way during your PBL is very helpful in determining whether the students are learning the information covered within the unit. Teachers would question how we could get grades during this process. By implementing these checkpoints, teachers can gather the data needed along with grades. These helped to ease the stress and helped them become more eager to implement in their classrooms.  One of the most important things that I learned was that you can build a PBL unit but you are going to have to make modifications along the way because nothing is going to be perfect. With my PBL, I started so over the top and ambitious. I have since learned that PBLs should grow and change with your students and their needs. They need to be flexible but allow some rigid components that students have to work for. With everything, reflection is key.  If you do not reflect on how to improve on the negatives, the PBL can easily be derailed.  The course itself helped to provide me with a better understanding of each specific PBL component. This was critical for me so that I could help to provide guidance for the teachers at my school as they undergo the process of learning and implementing PBL. 

Taylor Thomas - Course 2: Blog Post 4

For Genius Hour, I gave students twenty minutes of class each day for two weeks to become an expert in a field of their choice. Students were introduced to Genius Hour, given clear expectations, and given a Genius Hour Project Proposal document. I also provided students with a folder to stay organized specifically for Genius Hour. Once a student’s proposal was accepted, they were free to research and explore their topic. Students did a great job at choosing topics. A few students realized they needed to switch gears along the way, but I did not have to steer anyone away from their genius idea. A requirement for students was they could not easily Google or retrieve the answer to questions on their topic. Students worked diligently on their project each day. They would enter the classroom and pick up right where they left off the day before without even a reminder! Students chose various ways to present their projects. PowerPoint was the most popular, emaze and posters were also chosen as a method to present. Overall, students did a great job presenting. One of the requirements was to include audience interaction in their presentation. Some students asked questions along the way, some asked questions at the end of their presentation, and a few students left this component out. Students were also great listeners as their peers presented. Having so many different topics and students presenting what they are passionate about kept the audience engaged. I am very pleased with our Genius Hour experience. Students ask each day if we are going to do another Genius Hour Project, some began asking before we finished this one! J
What worked – introducing Genius Hour, setting clear expectations, providing students with folders and templates for planning and researching, CHOICE in topic and method of presenting, time frame/timeline
What didn’t work – some students are still copying and pasting from Google or websites (and forgetting to cite research), some students still do not understand that Google is not a website it is a search engine, half of my students need more practice presenting
What I learned – student interests, student’s families, their hobbies, what they would like to pursue in the future, research and presentation abilities, levels of responsibility, willingness to please and meet expectations
Impact of student learning - Students delved into learning about something that was totally in their control, could not wait to share their findings and cannot wait to do this again. Providing choice and leeway allowed topic/projects to become quite meaningful to students as learners of inquiry as well as teachers/learners of their peers. Some students will use their Genius Hour topic as a global issue in the Spring semester when we begin our next PBL.

Documents are in my Genius Hour folder in our Google Drive. 

Blog Post #4 Genius Hour


Blog Post #4 Genius Hour
When I first began to contemplate how I was going to approach this, I first had to keep in mind that I was going to have to collaborate with another teacher to carry out my vision. Genius Hour can be seen as overwhelming and unfamiliar to many educators on how to execute and effectively implement this in their classroom. My first logical thought was to test something like this concept in an exploratory classroom.  I decided to use an 8th grade Financial Literacy classroom in order to try my hand at Genius Hour in middle school. I knew the co-teacher was very flexible and willing to shift curriculum in order to make this happen. The other part to why I chose this group was because I was familiar with their varying degrees of ability levels due to having taught or co-taught within their 7th grade class.

Planning the journey:
The first thought I had was how to get students to buy into this way of thinking and the end project. I knew my first challenge was going to be this learning was happening in an exploratory class.  Although many recognize the importance, others do not apply as much effort due to it being an exploratory class. The idea I had going into this was first relying heavily on my co-teach partner to help instruct me on the varying abilities levels of the students within the structure of his classroom. This was of utmost importance and we constantly traded ideas back and forth so to make the appropriate modifications to the plan. Mr. Kirby, who teaches the class, had begun to lay down some hints that a project like this was going to happen very soon. This was helpful because the students were prepared when I stepped in to begin co-teaching. When coming up with the initial concept, I wanted it to be very much like an authentic Genius Hour. I wanted their interest to drive the heart of the learning. With this concept in mind, I decided that they would be able to research anything that they were interested in learning more about. This was even the way I approached it with them. The student would be given the background information of what Genius Hour was all about. Since this was a financial literacy class, I wanted to make sure that all the business aspects were connected with this learning process. Genius Hour was looked at in this classroom as a way to conduct a unique business approach with potential employees. From this, it was decided that students would take their interest and find a way to turn it into a business. The essential question, “how can I take my interest and turn it into a business” became the guiding focus for everything that we did in the class. I did not want to construct a ton of guidelines due to making limitations and felt that this was be something that we developed along the way. To get started, I pulled a video of Genius Hour and a quick Google Slide show to present the business behind Genius Hour.  The next thing I did was create a handout that gave them an overview all the components of Genius Hour, the expectations and how the grade would be calculated from this. At all times, I had to be considerate to my co-teacher by making sure he would be able to have some grades from this.  The other information that I constructed was a genius hour daily reflection log so that the students could chart down what they felt they had accomplished for the day and where they needed to go. They also had a note taking log that record their websites and notes with their information. Since Mr. Kirby has a Google Classroom, he uploaded all the important documents on here is well. I also had a template that they would use for their sales pitch and several rubrics for the items to be assessed.

The implementation:
The Genius Hour implementation began slowly. The first day, I came into the classroom and shared with them the video for Genius Hour. After that, we viewed the Google Slide presentation that covered all the fundamentals. The class spent their time discussing thoughts and asking questions about how this process would occur. We let them start to think about a topic that they wanted to learn more about. The next day, we spent the class period taking their topic and turning it into their focus question. The students were shown what are appropriate questions such as ones that you could not google and find the answer. Ones of the first struggles the students faced was turning their topic into not only a focus question but also something that would eventually become a business. Mr. Kirby and I spent the majority of the time conferencing one on one with the students to help them take their interest into a business. From there, we told them to begin their research. There were plenty of times students would start with their topic and then realize it was not something that they could really research, turn into a business or of real interest to them. After every session, Mr. Kirby and I would talk about things to improve, concerns that were noted and general just the sessions. It was during one of these talks that it become abundantly clear that more ground rules were needed with the research. Some students were stating that they were finished even though clearly their research lacked. We also discussed how some of the students were not as focused on the given tasks. From our reflection time, a new strategy emerged. We realized that more guidelines that are specific were going to have to be administered to help guide the students and make them more reflective of the task and work they were completing. The next day the mini-lesson consisted helping them to understand the importance of gathering five to six beneficial and reliable resources. They were shown how to take down the information to help them with understanding their idea so they can express it to others. This modification provided the clarity needed to help progress their project along. Every reflection session we had after class allowed us to redirect the desired learning and helped the students make sense of their task.  Students were either not effectively managing time, struggling to formulate their plan or lacked motivation. This lead to use deciding to separate the class into two groups. We would start the day out together sharing the mini-lesson while reviewing their goals for the day. From there, Mr. Kirby would keep certain students with him and I would take the rest back to my classroom. Another great idea that came from our conversations, were checkpoints. Each student would be individually conferenced with Mr. Kirby or myself. A document was constructed on our Google Drive so we could both be aware of what was going on. A series of questions such as focus question, research, next step, business plan and presentation were asked to the student in a one-on-one session. This became a great way to help students really step back and think about their project. It help us to learn where they were going with the project and the steps needed to help support them. I was blown away at the concept and levels of discussions we had during this time. It seemed to be mutually beneficial for the students. It gave them an outline of where they needed to finish and how to get there. Truly, I think without the reflective piece at the end of each session, these ideas may not have surfaced nor have been as organic since they were derived from students’ needs. The next step was to explain through our mini-lesson about their sales pitch. After much thought, I felt like using the elevator pitch method would connect back to my students. They would be able to take that model and curtail it to something that worked for them. There were two forms posted to their Google Classroom for them to use. While working on their sales pitch, students would have one-on-one consultations with me. They would practice their elevator pitch while I timed them. The dividing of the class helped exponential as well. It gave us more one-on-one time with the students, lessening the distraction and increasing the amount of work created. Students are now finishing their presentation to which I have already shared a mini-lesson on the rubric so they know what we are looking for. They will have to present this to a panel of three. The hope is not only focusing on their interests but also helping them to dive into public speaking, understanding how to start up a business and turning an idea into something concrete.

The Results:

Reflection with both teacher was the most beneficial strategy used during Genius Hour. By talking through the behaviors we noticed, Mr. Kirby and I were directly able to respond through mini-lessons, conferencing or desired expectation. It was amazing at how they took something that was of interest to them and turned it into a business. I really learned a lot from this attempt. Some of my new knowledge is when co-teaching, reflective discussions are a must, give guidelines but make modifications as the Genius Hour evolves to create more meaningful learning, mini-lessons are key, conferencing is a must to not only help you stay connected with the students’ learning but helping them stay on task. The way students presented their businesses were thoughtful and creative. It ranged from a reality TV show about a sorority makeover to fishing magazines for varying levels to packets for volley players to websites.