Wednesday, November 16, 2016
Jeneane Allgood--Collaboration
After reading both blogs and both rubrics, I really liked the BIE rubric much better than the New Tech rubric. I found the BIE rubric to be clear and concise, leaving very little to the imagination as far as what was expected of each group member and the team as a whole. The three elements that I found most important for my current class of students would be: taking responsibility for ones self, organization of work, and making and following agreements and schedule.
I liked how clear the BIE rubric was about taking responsibility--- encouraging students to complete tasks without having to be reminded and to complete tasks on time. From what I have heard, this is a skill that tends to be lacking in the millenial generation and one that could greatly be improved upon, so I put that as my number one.
Being a left-brained, OCD person myself, I liked the idea of students creating a detailed task list with responsibilities detailed for each student. When I assign a project, I like to leave very little gray area as far as what is expected of students, so I like the idea that with collaborative group work, that a detailed task list would let everyone know what they should be working on and when it should be completed (again---a GREAT transition to what is expected in the outside world).
Finally, I chose "makes and follows agreements and schedule". An agreement is only good if it is made by and agreed upon by the group. If people aren't willing to agree to follow it, then it is just a piece of paper. I also liked that it pointed out that students should, "Be honest about how well agreements are being followed"---in other words, are they looking at everything through rose-colored glasses and saying that everyone is on task and on schedule when they really are not.
I could really see myself using the BIE rubric. I think it would be very useful for the students that I teach.
Blog Post 4: Genius Hour Journey - Brittany
I did Genius Hour for the first time last year, and my
students loved it! I decided to do it on my Horizons day, as my students in
Horizons were doing their own version of Genius Hour. It was such a meaningful
activity to do on a day of the week when I couldn’t teach any new content. I
have been planning to start it again this year, but I hadn’t started it before
we were given this assignment.
For this particular assignment, I decided to do a modified
Genius Hour and do it with my entire class. I had originally been planning to spend a few
days (the Monday and Tuesday leading to our Barrier Island trip) doing a
Barrier Island Boot Camp to get my kids primed for their experiences at Barrier
Island. I decided instead to let my students spend a portion of those two days
working on an ecosystems genius project.
I began by leading a class discussion about ecosystems.
Then, I showed students pictures from previous Barrier Island trips (focusing
on wildlife, nature, etc.) and asked them to write down questions that came to
mind. We discussed questions that students wrote and differentiated between
simple research questions and questions that would work better for a genius
project.
Students then got the opportunity to spend time researching.
We talked about various resources that students could use for their research,
but since this was a shorter project, students focused mainly on online
resources (websites, Big Universe).
After discussing possibilities for how students could share
their new learning, students chose presentation formats. I have students
working on brochures, prezis, powtoons, powerpoints, and dioramas. We did not
get to finish before our Barrier Island trip, but students are getting the
opportunity to finish them this week.
This has really given them the opportunity to dive deeper into a topic
that interest them. I love seeing how students have gone in so many different
directions under one main umbrella topic. They are more motivated to learn, and
they cheer whenever I give them time to work on their projects… and that makes
me a happy teacher!
Collaboration - Darstein
Col-labor-ation!!! Col - together, Labor - to work, Ation - an action or process...Col-labor-ation - the process of working together. I'm not the English person but that seems pretty simple. Right?? NO!
Every class I've every had on the social development of 13-year-olds supports that fact that this is an up-hill battle. Bengard's article on collaboration and high quality work was well argued but it is rare that the stakes in my classroom are as intense as a bath in cold, murky water. I love my garden project and am witnessing some great collaboration but it has to come from an intrinsic place because there is no cold, mud bath waiting for failure.
Curtis' article was much more applicable to life in my classroom. When I say the motivation to collaborate has to come from an intrinsic place, that doesn't mean that I don't believe that we can guide students to that place. We certainly can and many of Curtis' tips are ways to do that. I have all of the methods that he outlined except for the contract. It just doesn't seem to match my style and efforts to help each student find their internal motivation.
My top two (third place was a tie) elements from the Collaboration Rubrics are Respects Others and Helps the Team. I don't have a third. In my mind if a teammate can be respectful and help the team, we can work on the rest. Every team member has their own talents and their own way of sharing them and these two elements allow work within a comfortable parameter.
Helping students learn to collaborate is really teaching them how to share...we started that lesson a long time ago. For a middle-schooler, at the most precarious stage of social development, we are now asking to take sharing to a new level, from objects to thoughts and efforts. Any progress they can make will set them on the road to future success.
Blog Post 4: Genius Hour Journey
Blog Post 4: Genius Hour Journey Shanna Pittman
After our last class and learning about Genius Hour, I thought about myself in school and how I would have loved being able to spend class time learning more about my passions and my many questions! This is an awesome opportunity for our students and I think it is an excellent opportunity to engage students in something that interests them. Having said that, it presented me with a few challenges.
As a kindergarten teacher, I am presented with unique challenges. My students are not independent readers yet. Therefore, they are not able to go to their laptops or grab a book and read about about what most interests them. It took several plans as well as trial and error to create a Genius Hour as close to the model as possible and still developmentally appropriate.
I began by modeling a few questions that began with "I wonder..." Since this was our first attempt, students stayed in a whole group as they shared what they wonder. When they had a sense of how to develop a good question, I began writing their questions on the board. Inevitable some students told me questions that I had already been written, and I excepted those questions since this was our first experience. We had seven questions written on our flipchart at the conclusion.
After I had the topics to research, I pulled books from my classroom library and the school library. I also created seven Blendspaces, one per topic and put the link to each on my class Tizmos page (which is the home screen on each child's laptop). The Blendspaces had some videos, images, and read aloud books on them. .Some students worked independently and some chose to do their research in groups of 2 or 3.
As they finished their research, we called them over to let them tell us individually about what they would like to create to share their newly learned information. Students created posters, wrote books, and created 3D models to share with the class and some special guests.
I enjoyed Genius Hour with my class and they surprised me with all they learned and the new questions that were sparked by their research. My ultimate goal was to take the concept of Genius Hour and make it something that is manageable for young children. I think I accomplished that goal and my students were excited and engaged. By allowing students to work collaboratively, even my students who are afraid to try new things because of fear of failure, were able to work outside of their comfort zone and get excited about the process.
Tuesday, November 15, 2016
Blog 1-Video Reflection
The lesson I videoed was my students participating in
their first critical friends. I chose
this lesson because I had never used this technique before and I wanted to use
this as a time to reflect for future lessons. I adapted the critical friends
protocol from this summer to best suit my student’s needs.
Each group had the opportunity to share their STEM
journal sketch, which included labels and materials needed for their piece of
playground equipment. After groups shared their sketch, materials list, and how
their equipment uses force and motion, the rest of the class wrote down one I
like statement and/or I wonder statement on a sticky note. Students then had the opportunity to address
the presenting group and share what they liked and/or wondered. The group that presented had to listen to
what their peers had to say and then gather the sticky notes. The sticky notes would be used by students to
make changes to their projects if they desired.
After watching the video I realized how animated I am…hands
are going everywhere and I can make some goofy facial expressions. J After
I stopped laughing at myself, I was able to focus on what worked and what
needed improvement. To my surprise, most
of my students stayed on task and had a good understanding of what they were
expected to do. I noticed most of my students
were engaged as other groups were talking and providing good feedback with
their I wonder/I like responses. I was
impressed with some of the conversations I heard as students discussed their peers’
ideas and sketches. One area of
improvement I saw was in the introduction to the lesson. I talked for over five minutes about what
they needed to do and my expectations.
This is something that I am going to try to be more mindful in the
future. However, even though I feel like
my introduction was way too long, my students did know exactly what to do. So I’m thinking the next time I should
explain it the same way, but don’t take as much time to do it. I also noticed that some of my students
became inattentive while groups were sharing.
I had one little boy in the back that played with his pencil a lot and
at one point was in the floor instead of listening or providing feedback.
My students totally exceeded my expectations on this
lesson. They were engaged,
collaborating, and open to hear new ideas!
I am excited to try this lesson with other projects.
Genius Hour- Darstein
I thought I would be clever and schedule my Genius Hour on one of our ACT Aspire testing days. It made sense at the time...I would only see one class on that day so I would be able to keep my classes on the same timeline. BAD IDEA! After two days of testing and altered schedules AND the biggest full moon of the century my middle school students were not mentally able to embrace their genius.
Don't get me wrong...they have the passion for some really great products. They were just tired.
I started the lesson by presenting the concept of Genius Hour to them. We watched the "What is Genius Hour" video as well as "How to Change the World by the Kid President". Both were very motivational and got the group thinking.
In lieu of a Wonder Journal, I put together a Wonder "Mix" using some old CD sleeves I had left over from the 90's. The 'mix' included some tables that would help guide the students through the Genius Hour process. I was happy to find these tables in Teachers Pay Teachers. The first table just helped students get in touch with who they really are and what it important to them. This is a very difficult process for anyone let alone a 13-year-old. I was proud of their progress through that table and watched excitedly as they moved on to forge their driving question.
As you suspect some of the driving questions didn't even make it out of the driveway...How fast can an arrow fly? This did give us time to talk about where these questions would lead them and the product they would be sharing. In the end most students came up with good questions. Some of them were even GREAT questions...How do I help people who might want to hurt themselves? What can I do to help abused horses? I am really proud of the genuine compassion showed by many of my students. As a "Wonder Wall" we but the questions on clear vinyl and posted them on the wall in the classroom.
Unfortunately, the eighty minutes went by all too quickly. Most students were still working on their research and one created a preliminary product. I invited and encouraged them all to continue their work and guaranteed them I would give them access to all my resources whenever they wanted to work on their research and product.
In the end my students came away with a little bit better understanding about who they are an where their passions lie. They also were reminded that they can make a difference and I am here to help them if needed.
The Good, the Bad, and the Collaboration
Oh, collaboration - what a love hate relationship I have with you. BUT, collaboration is such an integral part of who we are as members of the human race. Think of some of the problems we have as a society right now - reaction to election results, protesting/rioting, divorce rates, war, famine, genocide, and the list could go on. We don't all truly understand what it means to collaborate and neither do our students (now don't get all worried - I'm not going to get political on you). I think Mother Teresa said it best when she stated, "We have no peace because we have forgotten we belong to each other." Word, Mother. Word. This is especially true in my class that I am trying PBL with this year. They have no peace because they have forgotten they are all in this together. And, they have forgotten because I have allowed them to forget. I totally agree with Austin - PBL is messy. Collaboration is messy (see previously listed world troubles). However, that doesn't mean it is not attainable. And there is nothing I love more than making a goal and achieving it. So, that being said... It is on, Collaboration! It is on!
After reading the assigned blog posts, some of my classmates' blog posts, and reviewing the 6-12 Collaboration Rubric, I chose Respect for Oneself, Helps Team, and Respects Others as the 3 most important keys for my present class to successfully collaborate. Not sure if you picked on the fact that RESPECT is a need int his class. I like the idea of contracts and naively tried to do a class contract at the beginning of the semester, but that didn't work as well as I had dreamed it would (imagine that). I think group contracts for each group project would be a better bet in the future - we live an learn, right? I also like the suggestions for having students write the contracts. Finally, I would like to try the "self-grading" procedure posted in the comments of one of the assigned blogs as well as noted in Austin's blog. This may take some tweaking and all the rules would need to be established at the beginning of the semester, but it has promise.
Finally, I love collaboration because of all its positive results in society - healthy marriages & families, charities, missions, awesome companies like Google & Compassion & Samaritan's Purse, District 6's teacher forum, etc. I try not to be overly optimistic, but really, my classroom and my PBL attempts can be successful only when there is healthy collaboration within the groups and class. I have been disenchanted as of late, but am ready to give it another try. Peace, Love, & Collaboration.
After reading the assigned blog posts, some of my classmates' blog posts, and reviewing the 6-12 Collaboration Rubric, I chose Respect for Oneself, Helps Team, and Respects Others as the 3 most important keys for my present class to successfully collaborate. Not sure if you picked on the fact that RESPECT is a need int his class. I like the idea of contracts and naively tried to do a class contract at the beginning of the semester, but that didn't work as well as I had dreamed it would (imagine that). I think group contracts for each group project would be a better bet in the future - we live an learn, right? I also like the suggestions for having students write the contracts. Finally, I would like to try the "self-grading" procedure posted in the comments of one of the assigned blogs as well as noted in Austin's blog. This may take some tweaking and all the rules would need to be established at the beginning of the semester, but it has promise.
Finally, I love collaboration because of all its positive results in society - healthy marriages & families, charities, missions, awesome companies like Google & Compassion & Samaritan's Purse, District 6's teacher forum, etc. I try not to be overly optimistic, but really, my classroom and my PBL attempts can be successful only when there is healthy collaboration within the groups and class. I have been disenchanted as of late, but am ready to give it another try. Peace, Love, & Collaboration.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)