Because I made the decision to change my PBL unit to westward expansion after I had already started it, I do not have as much baseline data as I would like to be able to compare and see growth. I did have STAR reading scores from the beginning of the school year, and because this unit incorporated reading literary and informational text, I expect to see growth in my students when we re-take STAR later this week. However, I know that this unit alone is not responsible for all growth in reading skills. I did give a narrative cold writing prompt at the beginning of the year, and most students were weak in several areas. Ones that especially needed work were story development, character and setting, and figurative language. During the unit, I focused mini-lessons on these areas, and even though my students haven't all finished publishing their final writing projects, from my observations and conferences, I have seen tremendous growth in these areas. I also did not give a pre-test on westward expansion before this unit because the social studies standards are all new in fifth grade, so students rarely have prior knowledge on any of the topics. However, I realize that to truly see growth in westward expansion understanding, I should give one in the future. The majority of my students passed the unit test, though, with many making As and Bs, so I feel confident they learned the material well. Along with growth in their reading, writing, and social studies skills, my students learned a great deal about seeing stories from multiples perspectives, collaborating with others, solving problems by asking new questions and researching, performing in front of others, and time management. These real world skills are invaluable and will transfer to future projects inside and outside of school.
Not only have my students learned from our first PBL unit, but I have as well. I saw the benefits of infusing project-based learning elements in all curriculum, even if there is not always time for a full culminating project presentation with an audience. Inquiry, agency, collaboration, student choice, and real-world connections can be incorporated into many units and will generate more interest in the topics and better prepare students for problem solving in life. In my westward expansion unit, collaboration was high and helped students learn how to compromise and create within a group while still keeping their individual voices in their own writing. I also felt that the focus on point of view worked well because being able to see things from multiple perspectives can instill a sense of empathy, so the social studies content can be applied to everyday life. We connected our pioneers' journeys to bullying by reading stories about bullying from different points of view (the victim, the bystander, and the bully). There were some struggles along the way, of course, the biggest one being time. I underestimated how much time that collaborating, creating, writing, and practicing would take, and some of my well-intentioned plans had to be limited. This has also led to me being behind with regard to my long range plans. I also feel like I did not allow enough time for peer critique and feedback, which would have helped the projects turn out better, and our audience was limited to just another fifth grade class. For my next unit, I will continue with the elements that worked well, but limit the scope or time frame of my project (quality over quantity), plan for more opportunities for peer feedback and revision, and expand our audience to include community members.
Overall, I am pleased with the way my first PBL unit turned out. Honestly, I was skeptical about implementing some of these elements, even though I was excited about them in the summer. I wasn't sure how my fifth graders would be able to handle working in groups, researching independently, and presenting to a real audience, especially without knowing who they were at that point. Now, after getting to know my kids, I can keep my high expectations and plan for what they need and are interested in. Yes, there will be those students who do not rise to the occasion, but most will surprise you with what they are capable of as long as you show that you believe in them. I was not sure how interested my students would be in project-based learning, but after seeing the excitement on their faces when they presented, the in-depth knowledge they gained, and the questions of "Mrs. Barwick, can we do this again?," I know that, while difficult, PBL is worth it.
Sunday, November 27, 2016
Monday, November 21, 2016
Melissa Terry Genius Hour
Ten years ago, I was the Instructional Coach at Clemson
Elementary, and I worked with several teachers to begin two new classrooms –
Primary Multiage and Intermediate Multiage. The concept of a multiage
class is not new, but we were looking for an alternative to the regular
classroom for students who had difficulty (for several reasons) with that
environment. Basically, the Primary Multiage had 20 first grade and 20
second grade students with 2 teachers and the Intermediate had 20 third and 20
fourth with two teachers. Both classes are heterogeneously grouped.
Most of the teaching done in these rooms has been small group geared toward
student level rather than grade level, and many work stations throughout the
day that are collaborative as well as a time to work independently on
skills. The teachers in these classrooms used projects and self-directed
learning as a way to get students interested in their learning.
I close the IMA (intermediate group) to do Genius Hour for
two reason. I knew that they were used to doing some independent
self-study and this would be a good next step. I also knew that science
and social studies standards are always challenging for IMA. It is very
hard for those teachers to teach all of the third and fourth grade standards
and keep the integrity of this class. Basically, the more you divide them
up into grade levels, the less you have the opportunity for them to learn in a
multiage setting. I thought that Genius Hour might be a way to help
students dive deeper into those standards, or provide time for teachers to pull
small groups while students are working on Genius Hour projects. Either
way, I wanted the IMA teachers to have to opportunity to learn about it and
incorporate it the way it would work best for them. These teachers are
always willing to try new things and they were very excited about this.
I met with both teachers after school prior to my teaching
to go over the basics of Genius Hour. I shared parts from the webinar and
also showed examples. I went over twice and taught – one lesson on thick
and thin questions and another on notetaking. I met both times after the
teaching with the teachers to discuss Genius Hour and next steps. I also
talked with them about the many directions they could go in with this. We
talked about ways this could be used in their classroom.
For this first project, the teachers wanted students to work
under the theme of “Earth”. The teachers were okay with leaving it
open-ended after that, but they wanted students to research something under
that theme so it could tie into both sets of Science standards. I was in
agreement with this; although during my teaching, several students wanted to
know why they couldn’t do what they wanted to do. I told them they would
get an opportunity another time, and they were okay with that.
The teachers are still in the process of working through
this project and I foresee completed projects before Christmas. They promised
to invite me back over to see them. I also have had an opportunity to
share Genius Hour (just the basics) with some district personnel and we are
talking about times this could be presented to others. I would like to
practice some with it and plan to meet with some interested teachers at my
school to share this and get them started in this area.
I think what I love most about it is that students are
learning and they don’t even know it. They are so excited about new
information! It was so fun to see them wanting to learn more.
Thursday, November 17, 2016
Genius Hour = Genius Hour
So I felt like a genius when I started this, but I quickly realized I am an amateur. I decided to literally do Genius Hour for my genius hour assignment. I started researching, attended an hour long webinar (in which I was offered the opportunity to take an online Genius Hour course for the low low price of $120 - offer good for one hour only!), had my kids brainstorm, and promised them 20% of the time we have left (only 3 weeks) to work on their genius ideas. Needless to say, I feel like I'm drowning and am now only hoping that maybe I have sparked one kid's interest and maybe this will stick with him/her. I truly hope to give them 20% of our time to work on these projects (one wants to make stuffed penguins??? several want to make online games, one wants to make his own jeans, and one is learning calligraphy along with me, etc.) as many really seem interested. This will be a one and done project with this semester's group, but upon reflection over the Christmas holidays, I may try it again next semester or maybe more. It is definitely a lot of work and seriously needs to be it's own course at our campus! So, wish me luck, pray for me, but maybe don't ask me how it went because I afraid it may be an epic fail. To be continued...
Genius Hour
Due to several restraints in the PLTW curriculum I had few options to choose from. So, I decided for genius hour. We just finished the Automoblox car where the students had to recreate each piece of a toy car in the Autodesk inventor. In teams of seven, they either chose the windshield, tire, axle, bed, passenger section, passenger base, or the connector piece. A team leader was chosen and then pieces were chosen/assigned. After each student recreated their piece on the 3D software they had to assemble the pieces in the Autodesk inventor. The genius hour part was the students had to add something, of their choice, to improve the car. The students have added the following: muffler /flame throwers, people, windshield wipers, license plate, doors, sirens, and a steering wheel. There were numerous instructional videos on how to build the pieces of the Automoblox car and most of the kids did a studious job of following the directions. They were able to recreate the pieces to almost exact dimensions and the cars assembly pretty well. However, their true creativity and understanding of the Autodesk Inventor software shined through as they added items to their cars that they wanted to complete. My favorite was the sire. He was able to figure out how to make the outer piece of the siren glass (see through) but the inner piece solid. I saw grown adults cry in Columbia during the training on completing simple assignments. Yet, a 9th grader took huge strides in the software when he was allowed to complete items that he chose.
Genius Hour Post
Austin Baker
So, Genius Hour in my photo classes was really successful. I
thought it would be pretty good, but it was REALLY good. As I’ve been trying
everything on hard-mode this semester and working with the more difficult of my
two classes first, I was actually kind of blown away by what they turned out.
I came up with the idea for how to implement the assignment
almost immediately as we were talking about it in our last class meeting. The
kids would have a short time to brainstorm and prep, then a short time to
shoot, and finally a short time to edit before delivering, personally, their
finished images.
In actuality, I had to pare down the deliverable a little. I
originally wanted 3 shots, but after much complaining and gnashing of teeth, I
narrowed it down to one. That was a good thing, for two reasons.
First, I think the kids focused more on getting everything
right than if they had to shoot multiple images. Secondly was time. Having them
create, deliver, and critique one image per student took about 2 hours for a
class of 30 kids, even with me working to move things along as quickly as
possible.
I was surprised by the quality of work that came out of my
tough class; pretty much across the board they all did some of their best work
fof the semester. It engaged them, and they actually tried. I’m not sure if
that’s because they have to get up and stand beside their work, or because they
were just generally engaged with the assignment The shy kids obviously hated
it, but they got up and did it anyways. And, the one kid who really missed the
ball on the assignment didn’t want to come up and talk about his picture in
front of the class. I asked why and he proceeded to rattle off a list of all
the things he’d done wrong in the image. I think that he was embarrassed because
he didn’t take it seriously. Also, the list he rattled off including all of the
things I was going to say about it, so, I didn’t make him get up.
I think overall, Genius Hour was super-successful because
there were so many good thigs that came out of it, plus, it tied in so many
concepts of PBL> It’s authentic, it’s problem-based (how do I get a shot done
in this short amount of time?), it’s creative/artistic, it’s active, it has an
element of collaboration, it has responsibility (in that I put the kids up
beside their work), and it has critique (from both the teacher and from their
peers).
The conclusion my kids came to is that Genius Hour is basically
like every reality TV game show competition out there; you have judges come in,
assign a competition, you have limited time to complete it, then they have to
present and get judged, then a winner is called right away. It’s especially like
Top Photographer, which is a show
that just came out and is a spiritual successor to America’s Next Top Model, which we have been watching in class. In
fact, I think I’m going to take inspiration from that show next time and give
them a slightly more directed theme than this first one, which was “shoot
whatever you want.”
Wednesday, November 16, 2016
Blog Post 4- Genius Hour
I’ve always seen posts on Pinterest about Genius Hour and
being a Pinterest junkie who loves to try new things, I knew I would have to
give it a whirl. But when… I always have
these great ideas of the summer that I sometimes never get to due to time. So, when this was an assignment for our
class, I need this would be something I would want to try. It all started when I put a Wonder Wall in my
classroom. I didn’t introduce to the
student what it was. I just simply hung
it up. Being the observant 10 & 11-year-old
my students are, they asked immediately, “what did it mean?” I, then, explained to the students that
whenever they had a question about something, they could post it on the Wonder
Wall and we would research the ideas when we had time. I allow my students to post ANYTHING they
wondered about at first, but then thought about moving Genius Hour to a narrower
concept (i.e. Amusement Park Rides). This was an instant hit because my
students are intrigued with making random PowerPoints. After finishing their work, they will make PowerPoints
about their favorite bands, themselves, and animals.
I
absolutely loved giving my students this opportunity because I could openly see
the excitement in their eyes as I gave the instructions. I gave the students 3 rules: 1. You have to
research something. 2. You have to create something. And 3. You have to present
your research. I think these three rules
were sufficient for the students because we have been working on biographies in
the classroom. We have had mini-lessons
on researching information, citing a source, taking notes and determining
importance of information. Another
important mini-lesson we had was finding reliable sources. I think because of these mini-lessons; my
students were able to handle Genius Hour well.
Most of my students chose to make a PowerPoints and few told me they
wanted to create something different, like a fact book.
I think
this strategy has a major impact on my students learning for many reasons. One reason is because it kept my students
engaged in something they were interested in.
I told students that they could work on their projects whenever they
finished their work. They were able to
use their time wisely instead of wasting valuable school time. Another reason is the students were able to
practice some 21st Century skills for creating college and career
ready students. Students are able to be
creative, communicate, and research while doing something that interests
them. Finally, Genius Hour impacted my
students learning because it was fun.
Students were able to learn about something that they enjoy and take a
break from standards driven instruction in their eyes. While secretly, they are really using skills
that are necessary for them to be successful students.
Blogpost Homework: Collaboration
Blogpost Homework: Collaboration
In his article, Easing the Pain of Student Collaboration, Paul Curtis describes the importance of student collaboration and how as students get older, particularly middle and high school, teachers spend less time teaching this crucial skill. He suggests team contracts as one approach to meet this challenge. He lays out specific components for creating these contracts. He also cautions teachers to actually teach collaboration, value diversity, balance group work with individual work and benchmark and tracking to hold groups accountable.
The rubrics for kindergarten will be very useful for me this year as I continue on my PBL journey. BIE's rubric contains the essential elements for collaboration in early childhood and is written in a way that is child friendly. I can discuss the rubric with students and they can see how they are performing based on the number of smiley faces they receive. I love that there are not any frowns or other negative faces.
The group I have this year is overall a respectful and kind group of children. They listen to one another and always compliment one another. I would like to boost their confidence and teach them to encourage each other to share ideas. They tend to look to certain children for ideas and direction while working collaboratively, rather than each child contributing an equal amount in ideas and information.
The most important components in working collaboratively in any grade level are communication, collective responsibility, and community. When a classroom has a sense of community, I believe empathy and respect naturally follow. Collaborative work is only successful when students feel comfortable and understand that they each share an equal amount of responsibility in their groups. Students must also be able to communicate their ideas effectively, as well as give and receive feedback.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)