Tieraney G. Rice
Blog Post #1: PBL Implementation Observation
Whenever we have a visitor in my school, the students are always excited and eager to welcome the person or people. So, it was no different when Dawn walked in! All of a sudden, they all became a little bit more talkative than usual. Dawn got a chance to see how we begin our day with a whole group time which consists of welcoming everyone to school, setting up the calendar, and singing some songs. I had introduced the "All About Shapes" PBL project the week before. So, this particular week we were learning a song about shapes, and identifying/exploring 2-D shapes. After learning the song, we split the students into two groups. One group stayed with me and worked in small groups. One group made shapes using popsicle sticks, one group used manipulatives of various shapes to create pictures, and the other group used foam shapes to match to puzzles to make pictures. There were many conversations and discoveries in each group as the students experimented with their objects. The other group was with my assistant. She had a cube with a picture and the name of the shape on each side. As the students sat in a circle, she rolled the cube and asked students to tell her the name of the shape pictured on the side the cube landed on. These activities the students were engaged in during this observation were very beneficial and necessary at the beginning of the project because a major "Need To Know" for the project was the name of 2-D shapes. Once the students could identify 2-D shapes, we moved on to 3-D shapes.
Dawn's advice and feedback during this observation was very helpful!
Wednesday, April 24, 2019
Rachael Le Mee, Post #6: What I used to think, but now I know....
Way back when in the spring of 2018 when I started my PBL experience with an online course through Converse, I used to think that PBL could be the light at the end of the proverbial tunnel. The "thing" I'd been searching for in education that would make all the difference. Now, I know, after spending a year teaching this way, that it's the truth. Some people will just claim it's just the "latest thing" or that it will fade away, but I know that it is rooted in every single best practice I can think of, and I've seen the impact it has made on my students and me as a teacher.
Another thing I know for sure now is that PBL is a process. Getting kids on board might be a process. Getting colleagues on board is a process. Creating a school where PBL is the norm is a process. PBL itself is a process. It's ALL ABOUT THE PROCESS!!!!
I remember Dr. Terry telling us in August that we were on the high mountain top, and that we were about to enter the valley of darkness, and that he wanted us to be prepared and know that we'd come out of the valley again eventually. That was so true for me, but instead of a mountain and a valley, it actually felt more like a particularly wild loop-a-dee-doop roller coaster with TONS of peaks and valleys along the way... and a couple of moments where I actually felt physically nauseous from the stress of it all! :0
But now, the roller coaster is pulling back into the station, and I'm ready to go for another ride. It's never going to be the easy way, and there will always be loops and moments when the bottom falls out unexpectedly. But it's the best way for us to reach our students, to authentically engage them in their own educational journey, and to turn out human beings who are capable beyond measure. Human beings that will change our world for the better if we only let them!
Another thing I know for sure now is that PBL is a process. Getting kids on board might be a process. Getting colleagues on board is a process. Creating a school where PBL is the norm is a process. PBL itself is a process. It's ALL ABOUT THE PROCESS!!!!
I remember Dr. Terry telling us in August that we were on the high mountain top, and that we were about to enter the valley of darkness, and that he wanted us to be prepared and know that we'd come out of the valley again eventually. That was so true for me, but instead of a mountain and a valley, it actually felt more like a particularly wild loop-a-dee-doop roller coaster with TONS of peaks and valleys along the way... and a couple of moments where I actually felt physically nauseous from the stress of it all! :0
But now, the roller coaster is pulling back into the station, and I'm ready to go for another ride. It's never going to be the easy way, and there will always be loops and moments when the bottom falls out unexpectedly. But it's the best way for us to reach our students, to authentically engage them in their own educational journey, and to turn out human beings who are capable beyond measure. Human beings that will change our world for the better if we only let them!
Rachael Le Mee, Post #5: Impromptu PBL Workshop?!?! :)
Confession time: I somehow had COMPLETELY forgotten about leading a PBL workshop. Until Dawn emailed us on April 9th. Frantic, and in full panic mode, I emailed her back asking if I could reach out to the teachers new to my school this year that weren't PBL-trained and see if they had any interest in learning more about PBL from someone "fresh off the boat." She approved the idea, and I led my mini-workshop for four "New to Fisher" sixth grade teachers yesterday.
While it wasn't a huge turnout, I was thankful to see that 25% of the new teachers (we had 16 last year) were curious about what this PBL magic was that I had been talking about. (And I'm not going to lie, I also think that the teachers that came were all 6th grade teachers because they felt a teensy bit obligated because we're 6th grade colleagues together and wanted to be supportive... but, hey, I'll take it!) :)
For my workshop, I actually pulled together a variety of things from our cohort and also utilized a Google Slides I'd made for the first PBL course I had taken online in the Spring of 2018.
Here's the Google Slides mentioned above that I started off the workshop with, because it's more "foundational" stuff like the philosophy of PBL, the elements of PBL, etc.
Then, I passed out copies of my unit outlines (Pieces of Me, Journal Prototype, and What's Going On?), and we informally talked through my big takeaways of what I've learned this year as I implemented PBL. The trials and tribulations (anti-groupwork vibe, time constraints and sex ed jacking up my whole first semester, finding ways to get an authentic audience without having my own space...) and the contagious pure joy that I've seen on students' faces as their families or peers funnel through the door into my various classroom spaces to learn about what students have created and learned. I shared about how, using what I gleaned from last semester, I decided that the best way to do PBL for me was by beginning with individual projects, then moving to partner projects, and easing into group projects. (Note: This is certainly not gospel and may not be true with other content areas, but worked great for character education and for my students this semester!) I shared pictures of student work samples, and shared a couple of the group contract videos Dawn had recorded during my observation to show what the beginning stages often look like.... The thing I stressed most of all was to just. get. started. I encouraged them to pick one unit for next year, and begin with the end in mind. What did they want students to know, and how could they get there in an authentic way? I gave them a copy of the eight design elements, and shared this link from Buck Institute with them so they could see tons of great PBL project ideas.
I truly hope that these four left inspired, and that they will give PBL a shot next year! :)
Rachael Le Mee, Post #4: Monarch and Drayton Mills Visits
What a MAGICAL day it was visiting Monarch and Drayton Mills and getting to enjoy lunch with you guys!
Here are my takeaways from the day....
Monarch: It DOES exist!!! A place where PBL is the norm, students are driven by engagement, learning is meaningful, and teachers are all teaching with the same mission despite the differing content in every grade level. What I think I enjoyed most about this day was getting to hear from the teachers first about the good, the bad, and the ugly of "true life PBL" then see it in action as we walked around the building. I loved how in every class we entered, students were working on completely different things, but were equally engaged because their learning held so much purpose for them. Their learning was always building towards something, and the engaging work they were doing was part of a process, not a culminating activity. I also noted, and particularly enjoyed, that the furnishings in the school were developmentally appropriate and easy to move for a variety of collaboration experiences in each classroom. One of my biggest takeaways was from my discussion with the principal: I realized that, if a school really wants to be PBL and do it well, the teachers need time for professional development, and it needs to be consistent across the school. And the leader has to MAKE time for that to happen and allocate resources for that to happen. How much easier would it have been to have inherited all these "excessed" teachers and just let them teach how they'd always been teaching? But, by making a commitment to PBL as a school, everyone benefits and teachers and students alike are both growing!
Drayton Mills: What I really learned at Drayton Mills more than anything is that becoming a PBL school is a long, slow process. You can slap the letters on the wall and on the website, announcing it to the world, but the actuality is that it takes time to develop PBL greatness. It's crazy to see the beginning phase at Drayton and well-oiled machine phase at Monarch, and it was incredibly beneficial to see them in the same day! What I really loved was that so many teachers at Drayton were able to have the attitude and acceptance that this process was going to be slow, but they trusted that they were all going to get there eventually. (This is something that is particularly hard for me, as I want to have the skills down, like, YESTERDAY.) Something that I think will be incredibly impactful about Drayton is the foresight that went into their building design. It is truly designed to be a place of innovation, imagination, and creativity where students and faculty have spaces to come together collaboratively.
Tons of great takeaways from this experience, and so thankful to have been able to be a part of it!
Here are my takeaways from the day....
Monarch: It DOES exist!!! A place where PBL is the norm, students are driven by engagement, learning is meaningful, and teachers are all teaching with the same mission despite the differing content in every grade level. What I think I enjoyed most about this day was getting to hear from the teachers first about the good, the bad, and the ugly of "true life PBL" then see it in action as we walked around the building. I loved how in every class we entered, students were working on completely different things, but were equally engaged because their learning held so much purpose for them. Their learning was always building towards something, and the engaging work they were doing was part of a process, not a culminating activity. I also noted, and particularly enjoyed, that the furnishings in the school were developmentally appropriate and easy to move for a variety of collaboration experiences in each classroom. One of my biggest takeaways was from my discussion with the principal: I realized that, if a school really wants to be PBL and do it well, the teachers need time for professional development, and it needs to be consistent across the school. And the leader has to MAKE time for that to happen and allocate resources for that to happen. How much easier would it have been to have inherited all these "excessed" teachers and just let them teach how they'd always been teaching? But, by making a commitment to PBL as a school, everyone benefits and teachers and students alike are both growing!
Drayton Mills: What I really learned at Drayton Mills more than anything is that becoming a PBL school is a long, slow process. You can slap the letters on the wall and on the website, announcing it to the world, but the actuality is that it takes time to develop PBL greatness. It's crazy to see the beginning phase at Drayton and well-oiled machine phase at Monarch, and it was incredibly beneficial to see them in the same day! What I really loved was that so many teachers at Drayton were able to have the attitude and acceptance that this process was going to be slow, but they trusted that they were all going to get there eventually. (This is something that is particularly hard for me, as I want to have the skills down, like, YESTERDAY.) Something that I think will be incredibly impactful about Drayton is the foresight that went into their building design. It is truly designed to be a place of innovation, imagination, and creativity where students and faculty have spaces to come together collaboratively.
Tons of great takeaways from this experience, and so thankful to have been able to be a part of it!
Rachael Le Mee, Post #3: PBL Implementation Observation
I was lucky enough to have my coaching cycle back up to my "What's Going On?" Social Action PBL observation directly (March 19th and 20th, respectively), so I got the benefit of immediate feedback on whether or not what we had talked about together in the coaching cycle made a difference. And, MY GOODNESS! Did it ever!
We began Day Two of our PBL unit on a very different foot than we'd left off on Day One. We spent a quality chunk of time talking about what were our fears in relation to group projects in the two classes I'd be doing the project with. From those fears, we were able to come up with a list of what kinds of things we would want to specifically include in our group contracts so that we could avoid reliving group project nightmares. The students were sooooooo open to this, and seemed to breathe a collective sigh of relief as they heard their peers sharing some of their very own concerns. Some of the main ones were having someone in the group be a "steam roller" who paved over everyone else's ideas or working with people who were so checked out that one or two people carried the whole weight of the project.
With this all out in the open, students were able to meet up with their groups and have very different (and much more productive) conversations than we'd had the day before. As they began creating their group contracts, they were engaged, excited, and confident about their ability to make an impact on a problem in our community. They began creating their to-do lists, and most of them jumped right into the research phase.
One big problem we encountered during my observation was that, as students researched and got excited about making an impact, they started jumping the gun on what they were going to do and trying to start making a plan of action. (Example: one group learning about homelessness decided they were going to get tents for every homeless person.... which may not be what is most needed for someone facing homelessness. A group studying homelessness in another class said they were going to build 1 square meter houses! Both ideas were super thoughtful, but a little out of their league.....) We gathered as a group, and I gave them some examples of what happens when you jump the gun...namely that we become more of a hindrance than a help.
Our block wrapped up with students checking over their to-do lists and promising to get thinking about their Plans of Action before our next class.
All in all, it was a powerful second day of our unit, and I felt like my classes had come leaps and bounds in a short matter of time. It's amazing how far some thoughtful reflection on my part (with help from Dawn) can go to ensure that they all felt empowered and understood in their groups.
We began Day Two of our PBL unit on a very different foot than we'd left off on Day One. We spent a quality chunk of time talking about what were our fears in relation to group projects in the two classes I'd be doing the project with. From those fears, we were able to come up with a list of what kinds of things we would want to specifically include in our group contracts so that we could avoid reliving group project nightmares. The students were sooooooo open to this, and seemed to breathe a collective sigh of relief as they heard their peers sharing some of their very own concerns. Some of the main ones were having someone in the group be a "steam roller" who paved over everyone else's ideas or working with people who were so checked out that one or two people carried the whole weight of the project.
With this all out in the open, students were able to meet up with their groups and have very different (and much more productive) conversations than we'd had the day before. As they began creating their group contracts, they were engaged, excited, and confident about their ability to make an impact on a problem in our community. They began creating their to-do lists, and most of them jumped right into the research phase.
One big problem we encountered during my observation was that, as students researched and got excited about making an impact, they started jumping the gun on what they were going to do and trying to start making a plan of action. (Example: one group learning about homelessness decided they were going to get tents for every homeless person.... which may not be what is most needed for someone facing homelessness. A group studying homelessness in another class said they were going to build 1 square meter houses! Both ideas were super thoughtful, but a little out of their league.....) We gathered as a group, and I gave them some examples of what happens when you jump the gun...namely that we become more of a hindrance than a help.
Our block wrapped up with students checking over their to-do lists and promising to get thinking about their Plans of Action before our next class.
All in all, it was a powerful second day of our unit, and I felt like my classes had come leaps and bounds in a short matter of time. It's amazing how far some thoughtful reflection on my part (with help from Dawn) can go to ensure that they all felt empowered and understood in their groups.
Rachael Le Mee, Post #2: Coaching Cycle
When I met up with Dawn at Starbucks to take part in my coaching cycle, I walked in feeling deflated. I had introduced my PBL unit to two of my three groups the day before, and one of my best groups had fallen FLAT ON IT'S FACE when it came time to get started. They were hostile and frustrated and not engaged with their peers. What was going on?!?! They'd done an individual PBL (the Pieces of Me one I'd written for first semester) and a partner PBL (journal for teens prototyping) and been just fine. Meanwhile, I was having another group that was so "off-kilter" that there was no way I was willing to try another PBL with them having seen them struggle mightily with the partner PBL from the previous unit. Whatever the reasons for the struggles, I was feeling like a total PBL failure!
It was the perfect time to meet up with Dawn, and she helped me re-examine what was going on. We began by talking about students' behavior (how they fell apart) and some students' adamant refusals to work with others and what might be going on, as well as coming up with some options to work around that, such as the possibility of having students work alone and complete individual work contracts. Dawn and I also talked about my one class that "just couldn't handle PBL," and she reminded me not all of our students are ready for the same things at the same time, and it's OKAY to differentiate and offer different project options or less options or go with a completely different option because that is what it looks like if we're really meeting the needs of our students.
Once we had all those huge concerns covered, we moved into the meat of our coaching cycle, which focused on how to help students create meaningful group contracts that would help them build trust with one another. We came up with a sort of outline that I could provide to students via Google Classroom that they could then fill in and personalize for their groups' needs. Through our conversation, I started to visualize the contract outline in three parts: 1) the group agreements/promises to each other 2)the "To-Do List" that would be consistently updated throughout the project at the beginning and end of each work block, and 3) a Plan of Action to help guide the groups' service projects. I'm attaching a link here for y'all to see what I ended up creating, and a student sample to see how it turned out!
My blank outline
Student Sample Contract
Overall, the coaching cycle was a HUGE help to me, and helped us reach lift off (after crashing and burning early on) with what would become a really special PBL! :)
It was the perfect time to meet up with Dawn, and she helped me re-examine what was going on. We began by talking about students' behavior (how they fell apart) and some students' adamant refusals to work with others and what might be going on, as well as coming up with some options to work around that, such as the possibility of having students work alone and complete individual work contracts. Dawn and I also talked about my one class that "just couldn't handle PBL," and she reminded me not all of our students are ready for the same things at the same time, and it's OKAY to differentiate and offer different project options or less options or go with a completely different option because that is what it looks like if we're really meeting the needs of our students.
Once we had all those huge concerns covered, we moved into the meat of our coaching cycle, which focused on how to help students create meaningful group contracts that would help them build trust with one another. We came up with a sort of outline that I could provide to students via Google Classroom that they could then fill in and personalize for their groups' needs. Through our conversation, I started to visualize the contract outline in three parts: 1) the group agreements/promises to each other 2)the "To-Do List" that would be consistently updated throughout the project at the beginning and end of each work block, and 3) a Plan of Action to help guide the groups' service projects. I'm attaching a link here for y'all to see what I ended up creating, and a student sample to see how it turned out!
My blank outline
Student Sample Contract
Overall, the coaching cycle was a HUGE help to me, and helped us reach lift off (after crashing and burning early on) with what would become a really special PBL! :)
Sunday, April 21, 2019
Tina Sanders - Anderson Mill PBL Workshop Post
Anderson Mill PBL Workshop Presentation
By: Tina Sanders
Overview: I explained my project step by step from the simple to
more complex, educating the teachers on my process.
1. Explanation of PBL proposal.
2. 1st Steps = Student Engagement Piece: How did I
get the students excited about what they would learn? (Bullfrog Video)
3. Progression of PBL = I chronicled the highlights of the unit
from beginning to end.
A. Engagement
Piece (Mentioned Above)
B. Extension
·
Research - One video
per day that taught students about the animal of the day. (Each day, the students wrote a simple book
listing at least 2 facts about it.)
·
Directed Drawings -
Arthubforkids.com Students drew the animal (These drawings were created in the
book mentioned above.)
·
Food Chain
Introduction – Throughout the unit research, we discovered what each animal
ate.
·
3D Animal Creations –
Families worked to create a three dimensional representation of their chosen
animal. (Those who did not bring one in, were assisted in creation by a teacher
– Ex. Alligator)
·
Dioramas – Families
worked to create these highlighting their animal’s place in the pond along with
the animal’s food.
·
Food Chain Extensions
- Homework:
Students discussed with their parents their animal’s place in the food chain.
Then share with the class.
Game: Students acted out a living food chain.
Link: Students completed the page demonstrating
where their animal fits on the food chain.
·
Choice/Voice: –
Students were given their 1st choice in the beginning of the unit
when they were allowed to pick an animal they were interested in learning
about. At the end, they were able to choose – which product they wanted to
share with students, teachers and parents and which piece of technology they
wanted to use to share it on. (Paper/Pencil Creation, Video, Chatterpix,
Seesaw, etc.) Student Choice/Voice were highlighted throughout this unit.
4. Documentation Sharing – I brought student product samples
(3D animals, books, Dioramas, etc.)
Pictures and Videos of unit were shown by Dawn.
5. Question and Answer Period – I was excited to see that they
were willing to picture themselves teaching a PBL
next
year. I am also glad that they connected the
fact that if I could do this with 26 students, they
could definitely do it with 18-20 students.
Reflection: I actually feel like I learned as much from this
process as I hope the Anderson Mill teachers learned from me. I am encouraged
to know that there are schools who are on board with such inquiry methods and
that hopefully, mine will one day go back in that general direction. Reflecting through my unit once again, gave
me even more insight into ways to further improve this unit for next year. I
enjoyed being a voice for change. Thank you Dawn for allowing me this
opportunity to reach others in such a meaningful way.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)