Wednesday, November 30, 2016

Jonathan Terry - Blog Post 5 "What I Used To Think/But Now I Know"

I decided to create my PBL on density because it has always been a tough concept for my students to grasp.  Each year I look for new assignments, activities, and labs to aid in teaching density and every year I finish the unit still feeling like most of my students don't truth grasp its meaning.  When it came time to start implementing my PBL, I was extremely nervous about what would happen.  Would my students "buy-in" to the project?  Would the ships they create even work?  Would my classroom sink into utter chaos with different groups working on different types of projects?

After my PBL was over I administered a large unit test.  This test had questions from my entire Chemistry unit, not just density and buoyancy.  To put more focus on the PBL, an essay question was put on this unit test that asked students to explain in their own words how density and buoyancy help a ship float.  Data showed that 58 out of 88 students (66%) received full credit on the density question.  This was a little concerning to me.  I assumed this number would be much higher because of the project.  What I found was that most students could relate density to the ship project, and many even understood that the ship had a lower density than the water, but they could not relate density to mass and volume.  This shows me that students did make connections between the content and the real-world applications, but some still struggled with the exact science of the vocabulary.

Based on my reflections and the data from my density PBL, there are a lot of changes I will make to my next PBL.  First, I want to make sure that the concept the PBL is based around is the main focus of the project.  To make sure that students are truly grasping ALL of the material, I will put more individual benchmarks along the way.  These benchmarks could come in the form of reflections, quick-check grades, or even quizzes or tests.  I'm even flirting with the idea of creating a checklist of information students will need to show mastery of before moving on to the more "attractive" aspects of the PBL.  Second, I want to give students opportunities to work with different groups of peers throughout the entire PBL.  After teaching middle school for several years, I've noticed that students tend to get a little antsy within their groups after about 5 days working on a project.  For my next PBL I've already planned various activities where students can work with a partner or in a lab group before finally being assigned to their project group.  This will keep everything fresh and exciting so students don't lose steam heading into the second week of a longer unit.  Third, I want to do a better job having students collect the needed data throughout the entire PBL.  With my density project, students had a blast building and testing their ships, but when it came time to write their proposal, most groups lost interest and did not put forth good work.  If I have groups gather and write the necessary parts along the entire journey, then the final task of simply putting everything together won't seem like an uninteresting chore.

I've always said that I learn more by "doing" and that has been the case with these PBLs.  Actually implementing a PBL in my classroom has taught me a great deal about what I'm good at, but has also given me several areas where I know I can improve.  I'm excited to create and introduce my next PBL to my students in the spring.

Blog #5-What I used to think, but now I know...

                I chose my Force and Motion content as the PBL for this class because it was one of the units that my grade level has struggled with.  We have found the content not to be the easiest for students to grasp.  Some of the concepts and vocabulary is a review for students, but the other is an extension to their knowledge.  At the beginning of this unit, I gave a 20 question pre-assessment.  I told the students to try their best and to answer to the best of their ability.  Some students left some questions blank because they were unsure of the answers.  After going over the pre-assessment, only 17% (4) of my students scored 70 or above. After going through the PBL and taking the post-assessment, 75% (18) of my students scored 70 or above.  I think that my students did very well with the science content overall considering that several students miss some of the content due to RTI reading intervention and Speech services.
                I think this PBL experience was a memorable one for my students.  At RES, our students are familiar with the PBL process because began to implement this into our curriculum.  This PBL was had more of an excitement for the students because the loved the amusement park idea.  Even my students who have never experienced a roller coaster were just as excited.  One thing, I think my students learned was collaboration.  My students were able to work together throughout the unit during science labs.  They also participated in meaningful conversations during the planning stages of the amusement park rides. Some of my students showed growth in their area of research.  This unit allowed them to research something they were interested in and they wanted to become experts for their groups.   The mini-lessons then became meaningful for them because they wanted to apply it to their project.  The final area of growth that they grew in was Force and Motion content.  The students were able to learn 5th grade content and apply it to a final product.

 This class helped to improve my previous knowledge of PBL.  I was able to implement strategies that I had never heard of into my unit and other subject areas that I teach.  Next year when implementing this PBL, I will be sure to change a few things and most importantly add to the unit.  I would definitely change the pacing of the unit.  Due to the many unforeseen things in the year, my PBL unit lasted much longer than I anticipated.  I am going to look for ways to condense some parts without losing the core values of the PBL process.  I would like to make my PBL more cross-curricular.  After talking with teammates, we have discussed ways in which we can make this unit more integrated.  Another way this PBL unit could be enhanced is by public stakeholders.  I made the joke this summer for the students to visit places like Disney World or even Carowinds, which is more local.  After sitting with my team and doing a little more research we discovered that both placed offered an educational programs geared to force and motion content.  We also discovered that Carowinds offered Engineering Days as well as Education Days.  So, maybe this unit could be moved to the spring next year in order to accommodate those experiences.  I would like to also reach out to a mechanical engineer to speak to the students to provide a different learning experience.  After planning this PBL, I think I will think of projects much differently for my classroom. 

Blog #5-What I used to Think But Now I know

After reviewing my formative assessment (pre and posttest on force and motion), students showed a tremendous amount of growth.  Students went from showing little to no understanding of material to 19 out of 21 students scoring 80% or higher on the post test.  Students were able to use scientific terms to explain answers, label pictures to show push or pull, and show where friction would be.  My students also showed success on our summative assessment.  18 out of 21 students scored an 80% or higher.  The summative assessment had students apply their knowledge of magnets and force and motion.  I saw the most growth with my students STEM journal and science notebook.  I used students STEM journals from an introductory STEM lesson and compared to their journal for this PBL unit.  Students showed a greater understanding of the design process and terminology.  I also noticed students’ reflection on their project were more thought out and involved deeper thinking.  I believe this is a direct correlation to the inquiry based lessons, in-depth research, and multiple opportunities for collaboration, that allowed students to make connections and think through what worked, what didn’t, and what they could improve.
While I already had a good idea as to what a PBL should look like and how it should be executed (thanks to the STEAM focus our school implemented several years ago) I still learned a lot through the execution of this unit.  This unit allowed me the opportunity to stretch myself in the area of planning.  I have always LOVED to plan and try to “out do” my plans each year.  Each daily plan was well thought out; which I believe helped make the execution so successful.  I feel my plans provided students with numerous activities/lessons where I was the facilitator and they took control of their own learning.  Students collaborated daily; and sustained inquiry was something I really focused on.  This class gave me some valuable ideas, tools, and tricks to implement within my own classroom and allowed me to get out of my comfort zone.  Critical friends and building consensus protocol are two prime examples.  Both of these strategies allowed me to try something new and provide my students with meaning learning experiences.  These strategies allowed me to raise my already high expectations…and my students soared!

Some areas I would like to improve are presentation, co-created rubric, and community involvement. After discussion and reflection on last year’s PBL units, my team and I thought it would be best if the students first presentation be to another second grade class.  This would allow students to have experience speaking in front a group of peers and know teachers’ expectations for future projects.  During our Native American unit students presented to a kindergarten class and discussed the contributions of Native Americans and how it influences America today. Since students have now had two experiences presenting to different audiences, I am hoping to expand this to school personal and/or community members.  Another area I would like to improve on is co-created rubrics. This will be a completely different way of thinking for me, but I think it will make it more meaningful for the students.  

Blog Post #5---Jeneane Allgood


     When I chose my Cell Communication Unit to be my Project-Based Lesson unit, I knew that it was a unit that needed improvement, and that it definitely needed more student involvement.  To start out the unit, I gave students a 30-question multiple choice pre-test, and I compared it to the 30 multiple choice questions on the culminating unit test for that unit.  Students scored an average of 20% on the pre-test compared to 85.7% on the post-test.  So, they showed that they had learned the key content, at least over the course of the unit. What I am hoping for is that the retain most of this information for a longer period of time because of the connections they made when they did their Cell Communication Disease Project presentations. Students worked so hard on those projects to apply what they learned in class to the disease that they were researching.  They didn't just have to understand it for themselves, they had to be able to explain it to others, which the majority of them did very well with.

       As I reflect on what worked and what didn't work about my PBL unit plan for cell communication, a couple things stand out to me.  First, I need to change some of the disorders that I let them pick from---some were too complicated or there just wasn't enough research out there to really have them dig into the topic thoroughly and independently. Second, I would change the culminating project.  I didn't want them to be able to "copy" an existing cell communication image from the internet, and put that on their canvas, but that is what happened in a lot of cases.  I underestimated the number of good images out there that would be easy to copy. Third, I need to reach out more to community members to get them involved in the research process and to view the culminating project. Simply put, I was too nervous that these projects might not go as planned, that I was really uncomfortable with inviting people from the community until we were almost finished with them, and I knew they would be good enough to show. Fourth, I will need to work on individual responsibilities in the group work. I'm not sure if I will go the route of a contract on my next PBL, or split up each person's responsibilities a little more clearly from the beginning.

         In my next PBL unit, I want the learning to be a little more "truly" authentic---not as much regurgitation of information, but true learning in a hands-on format.  My next PBL will also have more individual responsibilities and check-points (as referenced above). Finally, I would like to have 2-3 different people (with different specialties) come in to talk to and help students (using their specific area of expertise) to help them plan the best way to help their seed to germinate. I would also like to have a more public presentation of their culminating project, open to a much wider audience. I will detail more specifics about this in my unit plan PBL for spring semester.
   

Jeneane Allgood---Blog Post #4 SAMR/Genius Hour


For my genius hour project, I chose to do 2 SAMR model revisions of my usual lesson plans for Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs). Normally, when I teach about GMOs, I do a survey (pre-quiz) to see what they already know about genetically modified organisms (uses for them and the kinds of food that contain them). So, I thought I could modify (the "M" level of SAMR) the survey/pre-quiz to make it more interactive. So, I made one on Kahoot and my students LOVED it!  It really helped them to see the kinds of things they would be learning about in the lesson, and what they should be looking out for or paying attention to. The kids liked it so much that I made them another Kahoot today for our Stem Cell lesson. My goal was to give it to them as a pre/post quiz to see what they had learned, but we ran out of time at the end of class, so I didn't get a chance to have them do it after the lesson.  I loved it, my students loved it (and learned from it), and I will definitely be using it in the future.

The other thing I did to modify (M level of SAMR) my GMO lesson was to have students use padlet to answer a question at the end of class on how they felt about GMOs.  My 3rd block's prompt was about whether they thought that GMOs should have to be labeled on nutritional products, and then they had to back up their stance with facts and evidence. My 4th block class had a different prompt--they were asked "For what kinds of situations or cases should we do genetic modification? When should it be allowed and why?". Again, they had to back up their opinion with facts.

From these 2 modified lessons, I learned many things. First, I learned that technology isn't as scary as I thought it was, and if you use if for the first time in a class of kids that will be supportive, they will actually help you troubleshoot any problems that you might run into.  Second, I learned that I have to figure out how to use Padlet a little bit better. I found Kahoot to be very user friendly, but I had a little trouble figuring out some of the settings on Padlet (for example, I had to "approve" everyone's posts,and that was very tedious---I wouldn't do that in the future).  Third, I learned that there are little things that you can do to "jazz" up your lessons that aren't that time consuming but that really make a difference in student learning. By starting these 2 lessons out with a Kahoot, I automatically grabbed their attention, and gave them a way to anticipate what they would be learning about.  They were more engaged than they would typically be in a lesson and definitely got more involved in our lecture than they usually would, so I really think it helped them to pay attention more closely, which is something we've been struggling with for a while.

I know some teachers have already been using Kahoot for a while, but this was a really big step for me, and because I had planned on using it as a "pre/post" quiz to see what they had learned, I felt like this was definitely at the "modification" level of the SAMR model.

Post #5

My students learned a great deal about macromolecules to include their structure, function, and how to identify them in due to their chemical properties.   These are just simple facts that both, in most cases, easily memorized and recalled for times on the final assessment. Students also showed growth and learned other items to include: how to act properly for presentation, how to dress professionally, and how to ask questions for a guest speaker.  Yes, understanding the facts about macromolecules is necessary for testing purposes, but public speaking skills is of greater necessity for future endeavors like job interviews.  For most students, they showed enough growth to where what they didn’t know (or did not demonstrate) was not detrimental to their grade they earned for the culminating project.   Out of the 24 students all showed growth but 3 students did not grow enough and it impacted their grade in the final assessment.

There were several items that did not run as smoothly as anticipated.  First, was some major assumptions.  I assumptions that the students should already know about presentations to include: seriousness, body posture, and using proper lingo.  However, after a very short practice session I found out otherwise.   Second, was the students would self-check as they were practicing.  Yes, they are kids and yes, I should have never assumed but I had it set in my mind that they knew this was their grade and they would stay on task better.  Also, was the time-line. I am a stickler for time and I set schedules for a reason.  In pained me to add a couple more days to the unit due to factors of laptops not working properly, students spending too much time on certain topics, and in other cases, students just working slowly.  

What I will do differently for the next one is more practice and critique.  This would provide a better gauge for me to evaluate where the students are and where they need to go to be more successful. Also, I will involve several English teachers (it’s in their standards) to help evaluate them during their practice.  Finally, the students can record their practices on the computers and go back and evaluate themselves to see how well they did.  



Tuesday, November 29, 2016

Blog 5 - What I Know Now

I added a column to my original Baseline Data document in my Google Drive to discuss what I have learned after the implementation of my PBL unit. Some of what I learned was not only based on this one unit, but my attempt at conducting my entire semester class in a PBL fashion. The link to my Google doc is below and is also in my folder in our class folder.



https://docs.google.com/document/d/1rCS88YuKqbW0uSSnUBvSh9wvvGmvsFFEuwnYcwq0qIM/edit