Thursday, March 2, 2017

Blog Post #1: Oh Mann! It was SO good to see other teachers doing PBL.

No, that title is NOT a typo.  Our PBL cohort had the opportunity to travel to a high school in a neighboring county: J. L. Mann High School.  We have been developing our own PBL units without seeing it done (except what we could see from online videos).  There is something about actually being there and getting to look and ask questions about the things that are impactful to me that seemed especially helpful.

I stole some great ideas!  Well, I borrowed with permission (but stole just sounds so much more impactful).  Some I put into practice within days of that "field trip."

Group student generated social contracts was one of those.  Students in my classes often say that they hate group work because there is always one person who gets credit for their hard word when they don't do very much work.  This gives students a mechanism for enforcing behavior and for firing a student who isn't doing their fair share of the work.  A student who is fired will either earn a grade of zereo OR they will complete a project by themselves.  You should have heard the classroom gasp when I explained that part of the contract system to them!

Others ideas, I put into practice in the weeks that followed.  There was great bulletin board that a teacher had in her classroom about changing the way that students things about school work.  I adapted that for a bulletin board that went up in the hallway for the entire wing of my school (see image below).



Still others I have on my future implementation list.

The most important thing that I was able to observe, however, was just how teachers managed a classroom when the class was doing projects AND learning content.  It was good to see these management techniques in practice and these teachers monitor and adjust to class needs in real time.

This field trip has left me feeling a lot less stressed about making PBL work in my classroom.

Jeneane Allgood--Blog post 1

My reflection on visiting the New Tech program at JL Mann:

I chose to do this for my first blog post because I haven't implemented my spring PBL yet, and I found myself thinking about the New Tech program and its pros and cons on many occasions since our February 16th visit.

After being slightly overwhelmed by implementing my first PBL unit in the fall, I was a little intimidated at how these teachers were able to teach (and assess) using this format--day in and day out---and still get the necessary content across. I was impressed at how most students were on task and very few were distracted or using their cell phones. Students seemed very comfortable with the whole process, from explaining how their group contracts worked to explaining (to us) what they were working on at the time. I was glad to hear that the teachers still give paper and pencil tests, which they called "benchmarks".

Pros--All (or at least most) students seemed actively engaged in their learning. Students are able to truly learn about a given topic and experience it instead of just being told about it. Group contracts helped to ensure that students are an active contributor to their group. New Tech teachers have a common planning time to evaluate PBL units and projects that they are working on with their students.

Concerns---As an AP Biology teacher, I found myself wondering how they could possibly "cover" the amount of material needed in this format, and the New Tech director did confirm that they were having a little trouble doing some AP courses in this format. I also wondered how I would feel about teaching an entire class using the PBL format with very little direct instruction. I feel like the longer I teach, the more PBL I will try to add in to my classes, but I'm not sure how I feel about using PBL to teach everything.

So, I'm curious what the rest of you thought about what you saw and what you took away from it? Maybe it works because students CHOOSE to be a part of the program and aren't forced into it? In other words, they are "buying into it" at the front end.  Share your thoughts with me!

Jonathan Terry Blog 2 - Implementation Observation

One of the main goals of my second PBL is to improve collaboration between students.  I not only want them to provide meaningful feedback within their groups, but also make sure that students are sharing the workload when creating their final products.  After visiting J.L. Mann, I was amazed at how students were able to collaborate through the use of Google Docs and Google Drive.  I loved how the technology allowed groups to simultaneously work on the same document.  I decided to use Google Drive as a major component of collaboration during this most recent PBL.

I first made students evenly divide up the workload of the project, writing their name beside the sections they agreed to complete.  This made the students accountable to their group members, but also made them accountable to me, as I could make sure each member was on task at any moment.  Students were then given access to a poster template that I created.  With the use of Google Drive, students could log into their group's poster and all work on the same document at the same time.

After the initial frustration of getting every student logged in to their district Google accounts, I experienced great success.  I was pleasantly surprised to see students help each other, both in working the technology and refining the sections they were creating.  Much of the collaboration was initiated by the students without input for me.  I hope to continue to use technology as an anchor for student collaboration as I implement more PBL experiences in the future.

Helen Reed - Blog Post 1 - 1st Observation

For my observed PBL lesson, I introduced what the students were going to be researching that day through the use of a focus question. Their questions for the day were: ‘What is pitch?’ and ‘How does our ear perceive pitch?’ These questions were part of the students’ “need to knows”, in order for them to be able to produce different pitches on their instrument they would create. By researching these things before, when the students do begin making their instruments, they will already know what they need to include in order to demonstrate different pitches on their instrument. Student began independently researching using the Symbaloo page I created with different websites, while I began to circulate around the classroom fielding questions and refocusing students.

One thing which did not work so well with this was having so many sources. There was really only one website which was geared towards their question on pitch for the day, so many students spent so much time looking through all the resources before they found one with what they were actually looking for. The other websites in the Symbaloo were geared towards topics of later research. For the future, I will spend a few minutes before the research time talking about how we can figure out the best source for our research for the day (as Dawn did during the student’s research time) in order to help them spend more time gathering information and less time searching for the best website.

From viewing the photos and video recordings, I learned that many of my students did not yet know, or understand, what they were doing the research for. From two of the student interviews, both hinted that they would be making an instrument, but weren’t 100% positive. One thought that I would be bringing in instruments for them to play, which he said ‘I don’t know how that would be helpful.” Thinking back, I guess I did not make it very clear to the students what their project would be. In our last PBL project, the students had the choice of what kind of project they would create (a poster, video broadcast, audio PSA), so I wonder if because I didn’t give them this choice they were not as certain. Or, I perhaps just wasn’t clear when explain it to them. Either way, the students did eventually get it and enjoyed creating their instruments when the time came around.

Monday, February 27, 2017

Group Contracts...Where Have You Been All My Life?


After our visit at J.L. Mann, I knew I wanted to try group contracts.  My social second graders thrive with group activities and collaboration, but often struggle with staying on task.  Before allowing students to pick their project groups, I presented the contract to the class, and we discussed the importance and components.  I was amazed at how students would NOT pick to work with their friends because they knew they would not be able to follow the rules.  One student said, “I can’t work with her because I just can’t control my talking when I am around her.” And another student said, “If I work with him he will want to do all the work and I want to have my input.”  My students GOT IT!  They understood the importance of working together and taking the contract seriously!  Fast forward to today—the day contracts were presented and rules had to be made.  Each group worked hard to generate rules that were important to them, and would help them be successful.  This one piece of paper allowed my students ownership and control, not just in how to present their information, but also in how they would work together!  I am so glad I decided to try these out and they will definitely be a part of my future project.          

Tuesday, February 14, 2017

Jonathan Terry Blog 1 - Grading Improvements This Time Around...

I started my second PBL this week.  When I started planning this unit back in December, one of my main goals was to improve how I grade students individually.  With my first PBL, I did not do a good job assessing the students individually.  Sure, I infused some formative assessments along the way, but I never took the time to assess each student's true understanding of the material.  I assumed that they must understand the content in order to complete the final group product.  When I gave my unit test, which included questions from our PBL, I was shocked at how many students missed those questions.

With this PBL, I wanted each student to show mastery of the content separate from the final group product.  I started out my PBL by discussing the "need-to-knows" with my students.  They will spend the first week working through assignments (some individual and some collaborative) to help them gather information on these "need-to-knows".  I also took care to make sure that my typical quizzes and tests are an integral part of the unit.  I want to make sure that each student shows mastery of the circulatory system before moving on the more exciting aspects of the project - building a mechanism to unblock an artery.

I hope this method will keep students more engaged, more accountable, and show more growth at the unit's conclusion.

Thursday, February 9, 2017

Autonomy

Autonomy:

As I am finishing up Unit 2 I am looking forward to my PBL unit on Zombies.  I have hinted at this unit over the last couple of weeks and I think my students are more excited than I am.  However, at this point, these students have 0 autonomy.  For example, today during the density lab if I was at the table the students were diligently working and completing the assignment.  Then, once I left the work pace slowed down drastically.  The same holds true for classwork and is very evident to the lack of completion of the homework.  The PBL will be difficult for the students to complete if their autonomy level stays the same.  I will need to find and implement strategies that increase the autonomy level.  Some of the students do not necessarily care about the low grades they receive for not completing work but maybe I can increase that with this interesting and relevant topic on Zombies.