Using protocols like
critical friends help teachers become more reflective because it allows us to
get feedback from our peers who may offer a different prospective based on
their experiences. At the end of the day, we should be asking ourselves the
same questions we ask our students: What
went well? What needs some work? How can I improve? There is no one way to
teach a lesson. My peers may look at a plan and execute it in a completely
different way than I would. It’s those “Hmm, I didn’t think of that” moments that
improve our viewpoint as educators.
Having a fairly
diverse group of educators is helpful. Diving in to a “critical friends”
session with administrators and teachers of various grade levels and subject
areas offer fresh eyes to improve the clarity and quality of our work.
With
Roots to Leaves, I plan to use the 3 Step Interview (with teacher guided
questions) as well as Critical Friends. One will be with a partner, the other
with small group (5 students), both for student-student feedback. For
student-teacher feedback, I will utilize writing conferences as well as a
staggered weekly checkpoint on Padlet. This will allow students to vent their concerns
as well as shout out their successes. I will watch their checkpoint videos and
provide individual assistance on the following school day.
Hi September,
ReplyDeleteI am glad you found the critical friends protocol helpful to you as you created and then revised your pbl unit plan and that you have built in multiple opportunities for critique and revision into your unit for your students to benefit from peer feedback and for teacher-student feedback.